New York and Montreal bagels are two of the most popular bagel varieties in North America. Bagels have a long and rich history, dating back to the Jewish communities of Poland and Russia in the early 17th century. Over time, bagels have evolved into many different types and styles, but New York and Montreal are two of the most well-known.
New York bagels are known for their size and chewy texture. They are usually made with a combination of high-gluten flour, water, yeast, salt, malt, and sometimes sugar. The dough is boiled before being baked, giving it a dense and chewy texture. New York bagels are often topped with poppy or sesame seeds or a mix of both.
Montreal bagels, on the other hand, are smaller and denser than their New York counterparts. They are made using honey-sweetened dough, which is boiled in honey water before being baked in a wood-fired oven. This gives Montreal bagels their distinctive sweetness and slightly smoky taste. They are usually topped with sesame seeds, but sometimes poppy seeds or other toppings are used as well.
One of the main differences between New York and Montreal bagels is their texture. New York bagels are chewy and dense, while Montreal bagels are lighter and have a slightly crispy exterior. New York bagels are often toasted before serving, while Montreal bagels are traditionally eaten un-toasted.
Another difference between the two is the dough. New York bagels are made with high-gluten flour, which gives them their chewy texture, while Montreal bagels are made with honey-sweetened dough, which gives them their sweet taste. New York bagels are also larger than Montreal bagels, which are smaller and denser.
In terms of popularity, New York bagels are more widely known in the United States, while Montreal bagels are more popular in Canada. However, both types of bagels have their own dedicated fan base and can be found in many bakeries and delis across North America.
In conclusion, while both New York and Montreal bagels are delicious in their own right, they have distinct differences in texture, taste, and size. Whether you prefer a chewy and dense bagel or a sweet and crispy one, there is a bagel out there for everyone to enjoy.
Quick navigation
What makes New York bagels different from Montreal bagels?
The biggest difference between New York bagels and Montreal bagels is the way they’re made. New York bagels are traditionally boiled before they’re baked, which creates a thick, chewy crust and a denser texture inside. Montreal bagels, on the other hand, are baked in a wood-fired oven and are thinner and crunchier, with a slightly sweet taste thanks to the use of honey in the dough. Another key difference is the shape – New York bagels are typically larger and wider, while Montreal bagels are smaller and thinner.
The two types of bagels also have different toppings and styles. New York bagels are often served with a variety of cream cheese flavors, lox, and other classic breakfast sandwich toppings. Montreal bagels, on the other hand, are often eaten on their own or with a simple spread of cream cheese and are typically enjoyed in cafes or bakeries instead of on the go. Ultimately, both types of bagels are delicious and have their individual charms, but their differences make them unique and beloved by their respective communities.
Why are New York bagels denser than Montreal bagels?
The debate over the superiority of New York or Montreal bagels is often a contentious one. While there are those who argue that Montreal bagels are better due to their sweeter taste and smaller size, others argue that New York bagels are denser and chewier, making them the clear winner. So, why are New York bagels denser than their Canadian counterparts?
The answer likely lies in the water. It’s no secret that New York City’s tap water is some of the best in the world, and it’s been said that the high mineral content in the water helps to create the dense texture that New York bagels are known for. In contrast, Montreal’s water is much softer, which could lead to a softer, fluffier bagel. Additionally, the traditional method for making New York bagels involves boiling the dough in water before baking it, which contributes to the chewy texture.
It’s also important to note that the history and cultural differences between New York and Montreal could also play a role in the differences between their respective bagels. For example, New York bagels have been a staple of the city’s Jewish community for over 100 years, while Montreal’s Jewish community has a much shorter history. This long-standing tradition could have helped to solidify the dense, chewy texture of New York bagels in the city’s food culture.
Which type of bagel tends to have a sweeter taste, New York or Montreal?
When it comes to bagels, New York and Montreal are two of the most famous and beloved cities in the world. Both cities have unique bagel traditions, but one difference between the two is the sweetness of their bagels. In general, Montreal bagels tend to be sweeter than New York bagels.
Montreal bagels are made with honey water, which gives them a slightly sweeter taste than New York bagels. They’re also smaller and denser than New York bagels, with a chewy texture and a slightly crispy exterior. Montreal bagels are boiled in honey water before they are baked in a wood-fired oven, giving them a distinct flavor that is different from New York bagels.
On the other hand, New York bagels are made with malted barley and have a slightly saltier taste than Montreal bagels. They are larger and softer than Montreal bagels, with a doughy texture and a shiny exterior. New York bagels are boiled in water before they are baked in a conventional oven, giving them a different taste and texture than Montreal bagels.
In the end, it all comes down to personal preference. Some people prefer the sweeter taste of Montreal bagels, while others prefer the saltier taste of New York bagels. But regardless of which city’s bagels you prefer, there’s no denying that both New York and Montreal have a long and delicious history when it comes to this beloved breakfast staple.
Are there any differences in the way New York and Montreal bagels are prepared?
New York and Montreal are two of the most popular cities when it comes to bagels. However, despite the similarities in their popularity, New York and Montreal bagels differ significantly in their preparation and even in their taste. New York bagels are boiled in water that has added malt syrup, and are then baked in a wood-fired oven to give them a distinctive crust. They are typically larger and denser than Montreal bagels, with a chewy texture and a slightly sweet taste.
On the other hand, Montreal bagels are made with a slightly sweeter dough that is boiled in honey water, giving them a unique shine and a slightly sweeter taste than New York bagels. Unlike New York bagels, they are baked in a wood-fired oven for a shorter period, which gives them a softer texture and a slightly sweeter taste. Montreal bagels are also traditionally smaller and thinner than their New York counterparts.
In conclusion, although both New York and Montreal bagels are beloved by bagel enthusiasts, there are significant differences in their preparation and taste. While New York bagels are known for their density and chewiness, Montreal bagels have a unique sweetness and shine that comes from their honey-water boil.
Can Montreal bagels be found in New York, and vice versa?
Montreal and New York City are known to have some of the best bagels in the world, with many enthusiasts loyal to their respective styles. Montreal bagels are smaller, sweeter, and denser than the classic New York bagel, which is larger and chewier. While both are boiled, Montreal bagels are boiled in honey-infused water and baked in a wood-fired oven, while New York bagels are boiled in plain water and baked in a standard oven.
Nevertheless, it is possible to find Montreal bagels in New York and vice versa, although not every restaurant or deli may offer both types. Many Montreal-style bagel shops have opened up in New York, such as Black Seed Bagels, Mile End Bagels, and Russ & Daughters. Conversely, some Montreal bagel bakeries, such as St-Viateur Bagel and Fairmount Bagel, have expanded into the United States and can be found in cities like New York and Miami. With the growing popularity of different types of bagels, it’s not uncommon to see both Montreal and New York styles offered at the same café or restaurant. Ultimately, it’s up to personal preference whether you prefer the sweet and dense Montreal bagel or the chewy and big New York bagel.
